In the world of gaming, there’s nothing quite like the thrill of making choices that shape the storyline. "Choice matters" games promise players control over their character’s fate, giving each decision weight and impact—or so it seems. But sometimes, despite the hype, these choices end up feeling like illusions, leading to the same outcomes no matter what path you choose.
From minor dialogue differences to entirely inconsequential endings, these games left players wondering if their choices mattered at all. Here are 15 games that made big promises about choice but left players with more questions than consequences.